BHMA Board asks why the Monument Square Landmark District Working Study report does not cite the Battle of Bunker Hill as a reason for the District

The Bunker Hill Monument Association (BHMA) board of directors has issued a public statement to the Monument Square Landmark District Study Committee and the Boston Landmarks Commission requesting an explanation as to why the Military events from 1775- 1776 which are historically significant on a local, state, and national level, have not been cited as a reason for designating Charlestown’s first Landmark District. There is no limit to how many ‘eligible events’ can be cited as justification for the district. In their letter, the BHMA executive board asks five questions and asks that the answers be entered into the public record and included in the MSLD committee’s final study report.

The full text of the public letter sent by the BHMA executive board to the Monument Square Landmark District (MSLLD) study committee follows:

“Dear Members of the MSLD Study Committee and the Boston Landmarks Commission:

The Bunker Hill Monument Association board of directors opposes the proposed Monument Square Landmark District and does not support its future adoption by the Boston Landmarks Commission. The Study Committee’s September 24, 2026 working study report says Monument Square “occupies the site of the main American redoubt” (Working Study Report, p. 12). It calls the 1839 house lots “preserved battlefield property” (Working Study Report, pp. 4, 12). Yet the report does not cite the Battle of Bunker Hill as a reason for designation, and it gives no reason for leaving the battle out under the events criterion of Chapter 772, Section 4(b).

We ask that the MSLD Study Committee formally address (and include answers to) the following questions in the public record:

1. Chapter 772 of the Acts of 1975, Section 4, expressly includes among its designation criteria sites “at which events occurred” that made an outstanding contribution to the “military” history of the city, the commonwealth, the New England region or the nation (Chapter 772, §4(b), pp. 1027–1028). Before any landmark district is designated, it also requires an investigation and report on the historical significance of the sites to be designated, as well as their architectural significance (Chapter 772, §4, p. 1028).

Does the Study Committee agree that the Battle of Bunker Hill satisfies the events criterion of Section 4(b), which expressly includes military history? If so, why does the report’s Justification for Designation (Section 1.5) cite only the 1839 subdivision under that criterion, and not the battle (Working Study Report, §1.5, pp. 3–4)?

2. The report omits two tablets/markers of the battle, at two different sites. Neither appears in the Justification for Designation or anywhere else in the report.

The Training Field (Winthrop Square): The report uses military history to justify adding the Training Field to the district, citing its militia training and its Civil War memorial (Working Study Report, pp. 4, 9). It does not mention the tablets the City of Boston placed on the Training Field in 1889 to honor the Americans killed at Bunker Hill.

30 Monument Square: On the granite facade of 30 Monument Square, a 1930 City of Boston tablet records that the rail fence, “the left wing of the Americans,” extended “to the Mystic River on the land between the present Polk and Elm Streets,” and that its defenders “protected the retreat from the redoubt.” The report lists 30 Monument Square in its building inventory (Working Study Report, p. 70). Its standards protect historic markers in general as building features (Working Study Report, pp. 48, 59), but the report does not identify this marker or the rail fence line it records.

3. On October 29, 2025, the Study Committee chair said battlefield recognition “is not within the purview of this study committee.” According to the minutes, staff explained that the proposed district “is about the built pattern of homes around the monument, not about recognizing the site of a battle” (Study Committee minutes, Oct. 29, 2025, §II.C).

Is the chair’s statement a limit set by Chapter 772 or another law, or a choice by the committee? If it is a choice, on what basis was it made? Who determined that battlefield recognition was outside the Study Committee’s purview? Is there a limit to how many criteria can be used to justify the district? Would recognizing the Battle of Bunker Hill under the events criterion of Section 4(b) prevent the committee from also recognizing the 1839 planned development and the district’s architecture under the criteria it already cites (Working Study Report, §1.5, pp. 3–4)? If not, why does the report’s Justification for Designation (Section 1.5) not cite the battle under the events criterion?

4. What role did redevelopment play in establishing the boundaries? At the August 12, 2026 meeting, the chair explained that Bunker Hill Street had been considered a northern boundary for the proposed Protection Area because everything beyond it had been redeveloped (Study Committee minutes, Aug. 12, 2026). Were battlefield parcels excluded from evaluation because they had already been redeveloped? Redevelopment may change the use of historic land, but it does not erase the events that occurred there.

5. Why are there no mandatory archaeological requirements for properties that sit on land where the battle happened? The 1987 National Register documentation describes the nineteenth-century residential lots as having been sold “on the preserved battlefield” (1987 National Register form, petition packet, PDF p. 34). Yet the working study report’s archaeology standards for these properties list “None” under “Requirements,” providing instead for review “solely at the request of the property owner” (Working Study Report, §4.4.2, p. 42).

We ask that the final study report:

1. Evaluate the Battle of Bunker Hill under the events criterion of Chapter 772, Section 4(b), and state its findings.

2. Explain whether the land on which the battle was fought, as a site “at which events occurred” under Section 4(b), was considered in drawing the proposed district and Protection Area boundaries, and if so, how.

3. Identify the legal basis, if any, for the position recorded in the October 29, 2025 minutes that “battlefield recognition” is “not within the purview of this study committee,” and state whether that position precludes evaluating the battle under Section 4(b).

4. Document the historic markers on the Training Field and at 30 Monument Square, and map the American redoubt, breastwork, and rail fence in relation to Polk and Elm Streets, the Mystic River, the Bunker Hill Burying Ground and other existing public spaces, and the proposed district boundaries.

5. Explain the absence of mandatory archaeological requirements on documented battlefield land.

The BHMA board believes the public is entitled to know whether the decision not to cite the battle, an event of local, state and national significance, under the events criterion of Section 4(b) contributed to leaving other battlefield land outside the proposed district. That land includes the rail fence line, which the City of Boston’s 1930 tablet at 30 Monument Square places “on the land between the present Polk and Elm Streets,” the side boundaries of the Bunker Hill Burying Ground (MHC Inventory BOS.806, p. 10). In 2010 the Commission’s own architectural historian found the Burying Ground eligible for the National Register because it “sits upon land that was the site of Revolutionary War fortifications associated with the Battle of Bunker Hill,” and MHC staff concurred, noting that the fortifications “may make this eligible under Criterion D as well” (MHC Inventory BOS.806, pp. 14–15). The report places the Burying Ground only in the Protection Area and makes no mention of its National significance but notes that it “is already protected by state law” (Working Study Report, p. 35). That protection has not kept other city burying grounds out of Boston Landmarks Commission districts. The Eliot Burying Ground, which the City describes as the site of the 1775 “Burying Ground Redoubt,” lies within the Eustis Street Architectural Conservation District (City of Boston, Guide to the Historic Burying Grounds; Eustis Street Study Report).”